Bakery: Pies

Loaded with crisp, locally grown Spy apples and a perfect blend of spices.

Our blueberry pies are made with wild Maine blueberries (a natural anti-oxidant) and just the right amount of sugar for the perfect taste.

Our cherry pie is made from locally grown cherries, has the perfect balance of sweetness and tartness, and is sure to please your pallet.

Loaded with locally grown Spy apples, a perfect blend of spices, and topped with our butter streusel blend.

This perfectly sweetened and fruitfully delicious pie is packed with blueberries, blackberries, cranberries, strawberries, and raspberries.

Our peach pie is a summer favorite, but don't worry, we carry it year round!

A perfect blend of pecans, brown sugar, butter and eggs—a hit during the holidays, but we carry this year round.

This is everyone's favorite at Thanksgiving, but we carry this all year—it tastes like a pie Grandma used to make! Perfect with a scoop of Oliver's Ice Cream.

Our raspberry pie has an optimal blend of tartness and sweetness. Leo's raspberry pie is the perfect pie for any time of the year!

This pie has just the right combination of strawberries and rhubarb creating a perfect taste sensation.

Our banana cream pies have a subtle and sweet banana flavor and are topped with our whipped cream.

This decadent delight has our fudgy brownie base, a generous layer of caramel sauce, and is topped with our chocolate caramel fudge parfait.

Our most popular cream pie, this classic has a rich chocolate pudding base and is topped with whip cream and dark chocolate shavings. Perfect for any occasion!

Indulge a little! This parfait pie will satisfy any chocolate craving. Made with chocolate pudding, topped with chocolate whip cream, and garnished with chocolate shavings.

A delicious combination of chocolate pudding and raspberry parfait.

A blend of vanilla pudding and shredded coconut, topped with whip cream.

Vanilla pudding topped with our connoli parfait and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips. Made with real ricotta cheese.

Our custard pie is a delicious blend of eggs, milk and sugar and is baked until golden brown.

Chocolate and mint! Chocolate pudding topped with minty parfait and chocolate shavings.

Tart and tangy key lime filling topped with whip cream.

Our lemon cream filling is tart and flavorful and topped with whip cream.

Our lemon meringue has the same great filling as our lemon cream pie and is topped with fluffy, golden brown meringue.

Get your peanut butter fix! This popular pie has a fudgy brownie base, a layer of peanut butter, and is topped with peanut butter parfait and dark chocolate shavings.

Vanilla pudding with a layer of strawberry filling, topped with whip cream.

Our Chocolate Boston is made with genoise, filled with our handmade custard filling, and topped with a chocolate ganache.

Made with genoise, filled with our handmade custard filling, topped with strawberry filling and whip cream.

This seasonal favorite is made with grapes grown in the Southern Tier and is available through the fall season.

This summer pie tastes just like a cremesicle!

This summer pie has a tart lemon filling and is topped with our homemade lemon parfait.

Our mince pie is an old time favorite, made with diced apples, golden raisins, currants, orange and lemon zests, and a special blend of spices.

Vanilla pudding topped with delicious strawberry parfait. A real summertime treat!

A perfect blend of pecans, brown sugar, butter and eggs-a hit during the holidays, but we carry this year round.

This is everyone's favorite at Thanksgiving, but we carry this all year—it tastes like a pie Grandma used to make! Perfect with a scoop of Oliver's Ice Cream.